Skip to content

Commit f7699a4

Browse files
author
Norbert Kozlowski
committed
Updated reviews responses
1 parent 652b71f commit f7699a4

File tree

1 file changed

+14
-18
lines changed
  • notebooks/publications/latent-learning-for-anticipatory-classifier-systems-in-discretized-real-valued-environments

1 file changed

+14
-18
lines changed

notebooks/publications/latent-learning-for-anticipatory-classifier-systems-in-discretized-real-valued-environments/reviews.md

Lines changed: 14 additions & 18 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -89,19 +89,15 @@
8989

9090
## Reviewer 2
9191

92-
### Limited abstract 📝
92+
### Fine-tuning Abstract section ✅
9393

94-
> The abstract is too limited, not clearly show the whole summary of the paper.
94+
> - The abstract is too limited, not clearly show the whole summary of the paper.
95+
> - Acronyms in the abstract should be fully written, ACS, ACS2, YACS...
9596
96-
**Response to concern**: ...
97-
98-
**Action to remedy the concern**: ...
99-
100-
### Acronyms in the abstract should be fully written, ACS, ACS2, YACS... ❓
97+
**Response to concern**: Agree
10198

102-
**Response to concern**: ...
99+
**Action to remedy the concern**: Abstract was partially rewritten.
103100

104-
**Action to remedy the concern**: ...
105101

106102
### Bibliography items ordering ✅
107103
> In the introduction section, the citation starts with ref [18]. why/How?
@@ -124,17 +120,17 @@
124120

125121
**Action to remedy the concern**: Highlight the memory-reward relation in figure caption.
126122

127-
### Try to identify, If the action/agent value has not a value of the reward, where is the punishment value will be updated?
123+
### Try to identify, If the action/agent value has not a value of the reward, where is the punishment value will be updated?
128124

129-
**Response to concern**: ...
125+
**Response to concern**: All of the investigated models support the distribution of rewards over created set of rules. The punishment scheme was not examined, and is out of the scope for this work. Additionally, the obtained reward is not relevant, because the internalized environmental model is learned without and explicit present of the reward (latent learning).
130126

131-
**Action to remedy the concern**: ...
127+
**Action to remedy the concern**: None taken
132128

133-
### How to classify the corridor and grid points for this work?
129+
### How to classify the corridor and grid points for this work?
134130

135-
**Response to concern**: ...
131+
**Response to concern**: These are the standard benchmarking problems used in LCS.
136132

137-
**Action to remedy the concern**: ...
133+
**Action to remedy the concern**: None taken
138134

139135
### Unclear figures ✅
140136
> - Figures are not clearly plotted
@@ -145,11 +141,11 @@
145141

146142
**Action to remedy the concern**: Changed the colormap to be more distinguishable. Lines and markers are also bigger
147143

148-
### Is the study applies multi-agent and action values. What are really agents are represented?
144+
### Is the study applies multi-agent and action values. What are really agents are represented?
149145

150-
**Response to concern**: ...
146+
**Response to concern**: This topic is not in the scope of the work.
151147

152-
**Action to remedy the concern**: ...
148+
**Action to remedy the concern**: None taken
153149

154150
### Stale references ✅
155151

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)