@@ -154,7 +154,7 @@ jobs:
154154 - Configuration patterns used
155155
156156 ### Step 4: Comparison and Analysis
157- Compare provider documentation with module implementation:
157+ Compare provider documentation with module implementation and perform detailed analysis :
158158
159159 **New Features to Look For:**
160160 - New `aws_ecr_*` resources not in the module
@@ -163,40 +163,188 @@ jobs:
163163 - New lifecycle configurations
164164 - New security features
165165
166+ **For Each Discovery, Document:**
167+ - **Feature Type**: Resource, Argument, Data Source, Enhancement
168+ - **AWS Resource**: Full resource name (e.g., aws_ecr_repository_creation_template)
169+ - **Arguments**: Specific new arguments with their types and descriptions
170+ - **Provider Version**: When the feature was introduced
171+ - **Priority Level**: Critical (security/breaking), High (major feature), Medium (enhancement), Low (minor)
172+ - **Implementation Complexity**: High (major changes), Medium (moderate effort), Low (simple addition)
173+ - **Module Impact**: Which files need modification (main.tf, variables.tf, etc.)
174+ - **Dependencies**: Any new provider requirements or version constraints
175+ - **Use Cases**: Real-world scenarios where this feature would be valuable
176+
166177 **Deprecations to Check:**
167- - Arguments marked as deprecated
168- - Resources marked for removal
169- - Configuration patterns that are outdated
178+ - Arguments marked as deprecated with removal timeline
179+ - Resources marked for removal with migration path
180+ - Configuration patterns that are outdated with modern alternatives
170181
171182 **Bug Fixes:**
172183 - Check Context7 for AWS provider changelogs
173184 - Look for ECR-related fixes that might affect the module
185+ - Document the specific issue being fixed and module impact
174186
175187 ### Step 5: Issue Creation
176- For each significant finding:
188+ For each significant finding, create detailed GitHub issues with comprehensive analysis.
189+
190+ **CRITICAL: Generate Detailed, Actionable Content**
191+
192+ **Issue Quality Requirements:**
193+ 1. **Comprehensive Analysis**: Include detailed findings from your Terraform MCP analysis
194+ 2. **Specific Implementation Guidance**: Provide exact resource names, arguments, and code patterns
195+ 3. **Real Provider Documentation**: Reference actual AWS provider documentation links
196+ 4. **Module Integration Details**: Explain how the feature fits into existing module structure
197+ 5. **Practical Examples**: Include working code examples with actual values
198+
199+ **Content Generation Instructions:**
200+ - Replace `[FEATURE_NAME]` with the actual discovered feature name (e.g., "image_tag_mutability_exclusion_filter")
201+ - Replace `[DETAILED_DESCRIPTION_FROM_ANALYSIS]` with comprehensive analysis from provider docs including:
202+ * What the feature does and why it's valuable
203+ * How it works in the AWS ecosystem
204+ * Benefits for ECR users
205+ * Integration requirements
206+ - Replace `[PRIORITY_LEVEL]` with justified priority based on impact analysis
207+ - Replace `[AWS_RESOURCE_NAME]` with exact resource (e.g., "aws_ecr_repository")
208+ - Replace `[SPECIFIC_ARGUMENTS]` with actual argument names, types, and descriptions from provider docs
209+ - Replace `[FILES_TO_MODIFY]` with specific module files requiring changes
210+ - Replace `[COMPLEXITY_ASSESSMENT]` with detailed complexity analysis including effort estimation
211+ - Replace `[PROVIDER_DOCS_LINK]` with actual Terraform registry documentation URL
212+ - Replace `[REGISTRY_LINK]` with actual AWS provider documentation link
213+ - Include actual working code examples with realistic values
177214
178215 **If NOT in dry run mode (${{ inputs.dry_run }} == false):**
179216
180- Create GitHub issues using templates:
217+ Create GitHub issues using these enhanced templates with detailed information :
181218
182219 ```bash
183- # For new features
184- gh issue create --title "feat: Add support for [feature_name]" \
185- --body "Auto-discovered ECR feature requiring implementation. See feature tracker for details." \
220+ # For new features - include comprehensive details
221+ gh issue create --title "feat: Add support for [FEATURE_NAME]" \
222+ --body "## 🚀 Auto-Discovered ECR Feature
223+
224+ **Feature:** [FEATURE_NAME]
225+ **AWS Provider Version:** ${{ inputs.provider_version || 'latest' }}
226+ **Priority:** [PRIORITY_LEVEL]
227+ **Discovery Date:** $(date -u '+%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S UTC')
228+
229+ ### 📋 Description
230+ [DETAILED_DESCRIPTION_FROM_ANALYSIS]
231+
232+ ### 🔧 Implementation Requirements
233+ - **Resource:** \`[AWS_RESOURCE_NAME]\`
234+ - **New Arguments:** \`[SPECIFIC_ARGUMENTS]\`
235+ - **Module Files to Update:** [FILES_TO_MODIFY]
236+ - **Estimated Complexity:** [COMPLEXITY_ASSESSMENT]
237+
238+ ### 📚 Documentation
239+ - **Provider Documentation:** [PROVIDER_DOCS_LINK]
240+ - **Terraform Registry:** [REGISTRY_LINK]
241+
242+ ### 🔍 Discovery Details
243+ - **Workflow Run:** ${{ github.server_url }}/${{ github.repository }}/actions/runs/${{ github.run_id }}
244+ - **Feature Tracker:** \`.github/feature-tracker/ecr-features.json\`
245+ - **Detection Method:** Terraform MCP Server analysis
246+
247+ ### ✅ Acceptance Criteria
248+ - [ ] Implement resource/argument in module
249+ - [ ] Add variable validation if needed
250+ - [ ] Create example usage
251+ - [ ] Update documentation
252+ - [ ] Add Terratest coverage" \
186253 --label "enhancement,aws-provider-update,auto-discovered" \
187254 --assignee "@me"
188255
189- # For deprecations
190- gh issue create --title "chore: Handle deprecation of [feature_name]" \
191- --body "Auto-discovered deprecation in AWS ECR provider. Migration required." \
256+ # For deprecations - include migration guidance
257+ gh issue create --title "chore: Handle deprecation of [DEPRECATED_FEATURE]" \
258+ --body "## ⚠️ Auto-Discovered Deprecation
259+
260+ **Deprecated Feature:** [DEPRECATED_FEATURE]
261+ **AWS Provider Version:** ${{ inputs.provider_version || 'latest' }}
262+ **Discovery Date:** $(date -u '+%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S UTC')
263+ **Breaking Change Risk:** [RISK_LEVEL]
264+
265+ ### 📋 Deprecation Details
266+ [DETAILED_DEPRECATION_INFO]
267+
268+ ### 🚨 Impact Analysis
269+ - **Current Usage:** [CURRENT_USAGE_IN_MODULE]
270+ - **Migration Complexity:** [MIGRATION_COMPLEXITY]
271+
272+ ### 🔄 Migration Path
273+ - **Replacement Feature:** [REPLACEMENT_OPTION]
274+ - **Migration Steps:** [STEP_BY_STEP_GUIDE]
275+
276+ ### 📅 Action Required
277+ - [ ] Plan migration strategy
278+ - [ ] Update module implementation
279+ - [ ] Create migration guide
280+ - [ ] Notify users via changelog
281+
282+ ### 📚 Reference
283+ - **Workflow Run:** ${{ github.server_url }}/${{ github.repository }}/actions/runs/${{ github.run_id }}
284+ - **Provider Documentation:** [DEPRECATION_DOCS]" \
192285 --label "deprecation,breaking-change,auto-discovered" \
193286 --assignee "@me"
194287
195- # For bug fixes
196- gh issue create --title "fix: Address [bug_description]" \
197- --body "Auto-discovered bug fix available in AWS ECR provider." \
288+ # For bug fixes - include technical details
289+ gh issue create --title "fix: [BUG_DESCRIPTION]" \
290+ --body "## 🔧 Auto-Discovered Bug Fix
291+
292+ **Issue:** [BUG_DESCRIPTION]
293+ **AWS Provider Version:** ${{ inputs.provider_version || 'latest' }}
294+ **Priority:** [PRIORITY_LEVEL]
295+ **Discovery Date:** $(date -u '+%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S UTC')
296+
297+ ### 🐛 Problem Description
298+ [DETAILED_BUG_DESCRIPTION]
299+
300+ ### 🛠️ Fix Requirements
301+ - **Root Cause:** [ROOT_CAUSE_ANALYSIS]
302+ - **Files to Update:** [FILES_TO_MODIFY]
303+ - **Validation Changes:** [VALIDATION_UPDATES]
304+
305+ ### 🧪 Testing Requirements
306+ - [ ] Update existing tests
307+ - [ ] Add regression tests
308+ - [ ] Validate with provider version ${{ inputs.provider_version || 'latest' }}
309+
310+ ### 📚 Reference
311+ - **Workflow Run:** ${{ github.server_url }}/${{ github.repository }}/actions/runs/${{ github.run_id }}
312+ - **Provider Fix Details:** [FIX_DOCUMENTATION]" \
198313 --label "bug,aws-provider-update,auto-discovered" \
199314 --assignee "@me"
315+
316+ # For security enhancements - include security details
317+ gh issue create --title "security: Implement [SECURITY_FEATURE]" \
318+ --body "## 🛡️ Auto-Discovered Security Enhancement
319+
320+ **Security Feature:** [SECURITY_FEATURE]
321+ **AWS Provider Version:** ${{ inputs.provider_version || 'latest' }}
322+ **Security Impact:** [SECURITY_IMPACT]
323+ **Discovery Date:** $(date -u '+%Y-%m-%d %H:%M:%S UTC')
324+
325+ ### 🔒 Security Enhancement Details
326+ [DETAILED_SECURITY_DESCRIPTION]
327+
328+ ### 🎯 Benefits
329+ - **Security Improvement:** [SECURITY_BENEFITS]
330+ - **Compliance Impact:** [COMPLIANCE_BENEFITS]
331+ - **Risk Mitigation:** [RISK_MITIGATION]
332+
333+ ### 🔧 Implementation Requirements
334+ - **New Security Arguments:** [SECURITY_ARGUMENTS]
335+ - **Default Security Posture:** [DEFAULT_CONFIG]
336+
337+ ### ✅ Security Validation
338+ - [ ] Implement secure defaults
339+ - [ ] Add security tests
340+ - [ ] Update security documentation
341+ - [ ] Validate compliance requirements
342+
343+ ### 📚 Reference
344+ - **Workflow Run:** ${{ github.server_url }}/${{ github.repository }}/actions/runs/${{ github.run_id }}
345+ - **Security Documentation:** [SECURITY_DOCS]" \
346+ --label "security,aws-provider-update,auto-discovered" \
347+ --assignee "@me"
200348 ```
201349
202350 ### Step 6: Update Feature Tracker
@@ -207,12 +355,35 @@ jobs:
207355 - Issues created
208356 - Scan summary
209357
210- ### Step 7: Generate Summary Report
211- Create a comprehensive summary including:
212- - Features discovered: count and details
213- - Deprecations found: count and impact
214- - Issues created: numbers and links
215- - Recommendations for next steps
358+ ### Step 7: Generate Comprehensive Summary Report
359+ Create a detailed summary report including:
360+
361+ **Discovery Summary:**
362+ - Total features discovered with breakdown by type (resources, arguments, data sources)
363+ - Detailed analysis of each discovery with provider version and impact assessment
364+ - Deprecations found with timeline and migration complexity
365+ - Bug fixes identified with specific module impact
366+
367+ **Implementation Analysis:**
368+ - Priority breakdown: Critical/High/Medium/Low with justification
369+ - Complexity assessment: effort required for each feature
370+ - Module architecture impact: which files and patterns need updates
371+ - Dependency requirements: provider version constraints
372+
373+ **Issues Created:**
374+ - List of GitHub issues created with issue numbers and links
375+ - Content quality summary: level of detail provided for each issue
376+ - Categorization: features vs deprecations vs bug fixes
377+
378+ **Quality Metrics:**
379+ - Analysis depth: how comprehensive the provider documentation review was
380+ - Content accuracy: confidence level in findings
381+ - Implementation guidance: specificity of development instructions
382+
383+ **Next Steps Recommendations:**
384+ - High-priority items requiring immediate attention
385+ - Long-term module evolution suggestions
386+ - Community impact assessment
216387
217388 ## Important Notes
218389 - Skip creating issues for features already tracked as "implemented"
0 commit comments