breaking-changes: deprecate support for core.commentString=auto

When "core.commentString" is set to "auto" then "git commit" will
automatically select the comment character ensuring that it is not the
first character on any of the lines in the commit message. This was
introduced by commit 84c9dc2 (commit: allow core.commentChar=auto
for character auto selection, 2014-05-17) The motivation seems to be
to avoid commenting out lines from the existing message when amending
a commit that was created with a message from a file.

Unfortunately this feature does not work with:

 * commit message templates that contain comments.

 * prepare-commit-msg hooks that introduce comments.

 * "git commit --cleanup=strip --edit -F <file>" which means that it
   is incompatible with

   - the "fixup" and "squash" commands of "git rebase -i" as the
     comments added by those commands are then treated as part of
     the commit message.

   - the conflict comments added to the commit message by "git
     cherry-pick", "git rebase" etc. as these comments are then
     treated as part of the commit message.

It is also ignored by "git notes" when amending a note.

The issues with comments coming from a template, hook or file are a
consequence of the design of this feature and are therefore hard to
fix.

As the costs of this feature outweigh the benefits deprecate it and
remove it in Git 3.0. If someone comes up with some patches that fix
all the issues in a maintainable way then I'd be happy to see this
change reverted.

The next commit will add some advice for users on how they can update
their config settings.

Signed-off-by: Phillip Wood <[email protected]>

y Conflicts:
y	Documentation/BreakingChanges.adoc

y Conflicts:
y	config.c

Author: phillipwood

Documentation/BreakingChanges.adoc

@@ -239,6 +239,11 @@ These features will be removed.
 +
 The command will be removed.
 
+* Support for `core.commentString=auto` has been deprecated and will
+  be removed in Git 3.0.
++
+cf. <[email protected]>
+
 == Superseded features that will not be deprecated
 
 Some features have gained newer replacements that aim to improve the design in

Documentation/config/core.adoc

@@ -531,9 +531,25 @@ core.commentString::
 	commented, and removes them after the editor returns
 	(default '#').
 +
-If set to "auto", `git-commit` would select a character that is not
+ifndef::with-breaking-changes[]
+If set to "auto", `git-commit` will select a character that is not
 the beginning character of any line in existing commit messages.
-+
+Support for this value is deprecated and will be removed in Git 3.0
+due to the following limitations:
++
+--
+* It is incompatible with adding comments in a commit message
+  template. This includes the conflicts comments added to
+  the commit message by `cherry-pick`, `merge`, `rebase` and
+  `revert`.
+* It is incompatible with adding comments to the commit message
+  in the `prepare-commit-msg` hook.
+* It is incompatible with the `fixup` and `squash` commands when
+  rebasing,
+* It is not respected by `git notes`
+--
++
+endif::with-breaking-changes[]
 Note that these two variables are aliases of each other, and in modern
 versions of Git you are free to use a string (e.g., `//` or `⁑⁕⁑`) with
 `commentChar`. Versions of Git prior to v2.45.0 will ignore

builtin/commit.c

@@ -683,6 +683,7 @@ static int author_date_is_interesting(void)
 	return author_message || force_date;
 }
 
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
 static void adjust_comment_line_char(const struct strbuf *sb)
 {
 	char candidates[] = "#;@!$%^&|:";
@@ -720,6 +721,7 @@ static void adjust_comment_line_char(const struct strbuf *sb)
 	free(comment_line_str_to_free);
 	comment_line_str = comment_line_str_to_free = xstrfmt("%c", *p);
 }
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 
 static void prepare_amend_commit(struct commit *commit, struct strbuf *sb,
 				struct pretty_print_context *ctx)
@@ -916,8 +918,10 @@ static int prepare_to_commit(const char *index_file, const char *prefix,
 	if (fwrite(sb.buf, 1, sb.len, s->fp) < sb.len)
 		die_errno(_("could not write commit template"));
 
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
 	if (auto_comment_line_char)
 		adjust_comment_line_char(&sb);
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 	strbuf_release(&sb);
 
 	/* This checks if committer ident is explicitly given */

config.c

@@ -1535,18 +1535,22 @@ static int git_default_core_config(const char *var, const char *value,
 
 	if (!strcmp(var, "core.commentchar") ||
 	    !strcmp(var, "core.commentstring")) {
-		if (!value)
+		if (!value) {
 			return config_error_nonbool(var);
-		else if (!strcasecmp(value, "auto")) {
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
+		} else if (!strcasecmp(value, "auto")) {
 			auto_comment_line_char = 1;
 			FREE_AND_NULL(comment_line_str_to_free);
 			comment_line_str = "#";
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 		} else if (value[0]) {
 			if (strchr(value, '\n'))
 				return error(_("%s cannot contain newline"), var);
 			comment_line_str = value;
 			FREE_AND_NULL(comment_line_str_to_free);
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
 			auto_comment_line_char = 0;
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 		} else
 			return error(_("%s must have at least one character"), var);
 		return 0;

environment.c

@@ -110,7 +110,9 @@ int protect_ntfs = PROTECT_NTFS_DEFAULT;
  */
 const char *comment_line_str = "#";
 char *comment_line_str_to_free;
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
 int auto_comment_line_char;
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 
 /* This is set by setup_git_directory_gently() and/or git_default_config() */
 char *git_work_tree_cfg;

environment.h

@@ -205,7 +205,9 @@ extern char *excludes_file;
  */
 extern const char *comment_line_str;
 extern char *comment_line_str_to_free;
+#ifndef WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES
 extern int auto_comment_line_char;
+#endif /* WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES */
 
 # endif /* USE_THE_REPOSITORY_VARIABLE */
 #endif /* ENVIRONMENT_H */

t/t3404-rebase-interactive.sh

@@ -1176,7 +1176,7 @@ test_expect_success 'rebase -i respects core.commentchar' '
 	test B = $(git cat-file commit HEAD^ | sed -ne \$p)
 '
 
-test_expect_success 'rebase -i respects core.commentchar=auto' '
+test_expect_success !WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES 'rebase -i respects core.commentchar=auto' '
 	test_config core.commentchar auto &&
 	write_script copy-edit-script.sh <<-\EOF &&
 	cp "$1" edit-script

t/t7502-commit-porcelain.sh

@@ -956,13 +956,13 @@ test_expect_success 'commit --status with custom comment character' '
 	test_grep "^; Changes to be committed:" .git/COMMIT_EDITMSG
 '
 
-test_expect_success 'switch core.commentchar' '
+test_expect_success !WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES 'switch core.commentchar' '
 	test_commit "#foo" foo &&
 	GIT_EDITOR=.git/FAKE_EDITOR git -c core.commentChar=auto commit --amend &&
 	test_grep "^; Changes to be committed:" .git/COMMIT_EDITMSG
 '
 
-test_expect_success 'switch core.commentchar but out of options' '
+test_expect_success !WITH_BREAKING_CHANGES 'switch core.commentchar but out of options' '
 	cat >text <<\EOF &&
 # 1
 ; 2