diff --git a/src/pytest_html/result.py b/src/pytest_html/result.py
index f791e6d7..c6e6e602 100644
--- a/src/pytest_html/result.py
+++ b/src/pytest_html/result.py
@@ -40,7 +40,6 @@ def __init__(self, outcome, report, logfile, config):
         self.append_log_html(
             report,
             self.additional_html,
-            config.option.capture,
             config.option.showcapture,
         )
 
@@ -175,7 +174,7 @@ def _format_time(self, report):
             duration_as_gmtime = time.gmtime(report.duration)
             return time.strftime(duration_formatter, duration_as_gmtime)
 
-    def _populate_html_log_div(self, log, report):
+    def _populate_html_log_div(self, log, report, show_capture):
         if report.longrepr:
             # longreprtext is only filled out on failure by pytest
             #    otherwise will be None.
@@ -194,8 +193,13 @@ def _populate_html_log_div(self, log, report):
                         log.append(raw(escape(line)))
                 log.append(html.br())
 
+        if show_capture == "no":
+            return
+
         for section in report.sections:
             header, content = map(escape, section)
+            if show_capture != "all" and show_capture not in header:
+                continue
             log.append(f" {header:-^80} ")
             log.append(html.br())
 
@@ -214,16 +218,11 @@ def append_log_html(
         self,
         report,
         additional_html,
-        pytest_capture_value,
         pytest_show_capture_value,
     ):
         log = html.div(class_="log")
 
-        should_skip_captured_output = pytest_capture_value == "no"
-        if report.outcome == "failed" and not should_skip_captured_output:
-            should_skip_captured_output = pytest_show_capture_value == "no"
-        if not should_skip_captured_output:
-            self._populate_html_log_div(log, report)
+        self._populate_html_log_div(log, report, pytest_show_capture_value)
 
         if len(log) == 0:
             log = html.div(class_="empty log")
diff --git a/testing/test_pytest_html.py b/testing/test_pytest_html.py
index 69341caf..5cc9a1a4 100644
--- a/testing/test_pytest_html.py
+++ b/testing/test_pytest_html.py
@@ -1152,27 +1152,28 @@ def test_setup(teardown):
         assert "this is the test case" in html
 
     @pytest.mark.parametrize(
-        "capture_flag, should_capture",
-        [("-s", False), ("--capture=no", False), ("--capture=sys", True)],
+        "show_capture_flag, should_capture",
+        [("--show-capture=no", False), ("--show-capture=all", True)],
     )
-    def test_extra_log_reporting_respects_capture_no(
-        self, testdir, capture_flag, should_capture
+    def test_extra_log_reporting_respects_show_capture_no(
+        self, testdir, show_capture_flag, should_capture
     ):
         testdir.makepyfile(
             """
             import sys
-            def test_capture_no():
+            def test_show_capture_no():
                 print("stdout print line")
                 print("stderr print line", file=sys.stderr)
+                assert False
         """
         )
 
-        result, html = run(testdir, "report.html", capture_flag)
-        assert result.ret == 0
-        assert_results(html)
+        result, html = run(testdir, "report.html", show_capture_flag)
+        assert result.ret == 1
+        assert_results(html, passed=0, failed=1)
 
         extra_log_div_regex = re.compile(
-            '<div class="log"> -+Captured stdout call-+ <br/>stdout print line\n<br/> '
+            '<div class="log">.*-+Captured stdout call-+ <br/>stdout print line\n<br/> '
             "-+Captured stderr call-+ <br/>stderr print line\n<br/></div>"
         )
         if should_capture:
@@ -1181,33 +1182,44 @@ def test_capture_no():
             assert extra_log_div_regex.search(html) is None
 
     @pytest.mark.parametrize(
-        "show_capture_flag, should_capture",
-        [("--show-capture=no", False), ("--show-capture=all", True)],
+        "show_capture_flag, html_log",
+        [
+            ("--show-capture=no", []),
+            ("--show-capture=all", ["stdout", "stderr", "log"]),
+            ("--show-capture=stdout", ["stdout"]),
+            ("--show-capture=stderr", ["stderr"]),
+            ("--show-capture=log", ["log"]),
+        ],
     )
-    def test_extra_log_reporting_respects_show_capture_no(
-        self, testdir, show_capture_flag, should_capture
+    def test_extra_log_reporting_respects_show_capture(
+        self, testdir, show_capture_flag, html_log
     ):
         testdir.makepyfile(
             """
             import sys
-            def test_show_capture_no():
+            import logging
+            def test_show_capture():
                 print("stdout print line")
                 print("stderr print line", file=sys.stderr)
+                logging.warning("log print line")
                 assert False
         """
         )
 
         result, html = run(testdir, "report.html", show_capture_flag)
         assert result.ret == 1
-        assert_results(html, passed=0, failed=1)
+        assert_results(html, failed=1, passed=0)
 
-        extra_log_div_regex = re.compile(
-            '<div class="log">.*-+Captured stdout call-+ <br/>stdout print line\n<br/> '
-            "-+Captured stderr call-+ <br/>stderr print line\n<br/></div>"
-        )
-        if should_capture:
-            assert extra_log_div_regex.search(html) is not None
-        else:
+        for log_key in html_log:
+            extra_log_div_regex = re.compile(
+                f" -+Captured {log_key} call-+ <br/>.*{log_key} print line\n?<br/>"
+            )
+            assert extra_log_div_regex.search(html)
+
+        if not html_log:
+            extra_log_div_regex = re.compile(
+                " -+Captured \\w+ call-+ <br/>.* print line\n<br/>"
+            )
             assert extra_log_div_regex.search(html) is None
 
     def test_environment_table_redact_list(self, testdir):