Split the download and install process of a gem:

- ### Problem

  Bundler awaits for the dependencies of a gem to be download and installed
  before it proceeds to downloading and installing the dependency itself.
  This creates a bottleneck at the end of the installation process and
  block a thread unnecessarily.

  ### Details

  The installation strategy in Bundler is to await for "leaf gems" to
  be download/installed before the "root gem" is processed.

  For instance, in this scenario:

  - Gem "foo" has a dependency on "bar" (We can call this the "root gem")
  - Gem "bar" has no dependency (We call cal this the "leaf gems")
  - A Gemfile adds "gem 'foo'"

  In this case, only a single thread will have work to do, that is
  because Bundler will queue the gem "bar" to be downloaded and
  installed, and only when "bar" is finished, then Bundler will queue
  work for "foo".

  For **pure ruby gems**, this strategy is a waste of time because
  during the installation, a gem's code is not evaluated and no
  "require" statement is evaluated.

  For gems with native extensions, this strategy make sense. When the
  `extconf.rb` of a gem is evaluated, it's possible that the extconf
  requires a dependency and therefore Bundler needs to wait for those
  dependencies to be installed before it can execute the extconf.
  A typical example is a native extension that require 'mini_portile2'.

  ### Solution

  From the explanation above, I'd like to split the download from
  the installation of a gem.

  The tricky aspect is that there is no RubyGems API to know whether
  a gem has a native extension. The only way to know is after we
  download the gem and read the `metadata` from the tarball.

  So the solution in this patch is as follow:

  1. We download all gems without doing any checks.
  2. Once the gems are downloaded, we now know whether a gem has a
     native extensions.
  3. If a gem is a pure ruby gems, we install it without waiting.
  4. If a gem has a native extension, we check whether its dependencies
     are installed. If a dependency is not yet installed, we put back
     the gem in the queue. It will be dequeued later on and we'll redo
     this logic.

  ### Performance gain

  The speed gain highly depends on how deep the dependency tree is.
  E.g. bar depends on foo which depends on baz which depends on jane ...
  Previously we'd proceed to installing gems just one by one and only
  a single thread would be used.

  In a freshly generated Rails application, the speed gain is not that
  important. And the reason is because we are having a "tail latency"
  issue. Around the end of the installation process, the remaining
  gems to be installed are the one with native extensions, since we
  had to wait for for their dependencies to be installed. Compiling
  them is the slowest part, and since we are doing it at the end then
  the speed gain is not that noticeable.

  ### Misc

  Another advantage of this change is to be able to more easily
  implement this kind of feature #9138
  to let users solely download gems, without installing them .

Author: Edouard-chin

bundler/lib/bundler/installer/gem_installer.rb

@@ -25,6 +25,20 @@ def install_from_spec
       [false, specific_failure_message(e)]
     end
 
+    def download
+      spec.source.download(
+        spec,
+        force: force,
+        local: local,
+        build_args: Array(spec_settings),
+        previous_spec: previous_spec,
+      )
+
+      [true, nil]
+    rescue Bundler::BundlerError => e
+      [false, specific_failure_message(e)]
+    end
+
     private
 
     def specific_failure_message(e)

bundler/lib/bundler/installer/parallel_installer.rb

@@ -32,6 +32,12 @@ def ready_to_enqueue?
         state == :none
       end
 
+      def ready_to_install?(installed_specs)
+        return false unless state == :downloaded
+
+        spec.extensions.none? || dependencies_installed?(installed_specs)
+      end
+
       def has_post_install_message?
         !post_install_message.empty?
       end
@@ -84,6 +90,7 @@ def initialize(installer, all_specs, size, standalone, force, local: false, skip
 
     def call
       if @rake
+        do_download(@rake, 0)
         do_install(@rake, 0)
         Gem::Specification.reset
       end
@@ -107,26 +114,54 @@ def failed_specs
     end
 
     def install_with_worker
-      enqueue_specs
-      process_specs until finished_installing?
+      installed_specs = {}
+      enqueue_specs(installed_specs)
+
+      process_specs(installed_specs) until finished_installing?
     end
 
     def install_serially
       until finished_installing?
         raise "failed to find a spec to enqueue while installing serially" unless spec_install = @specs.find(&:ready_to_enqueue?)
         spec_install.state = :enqueued
+        do_download(spec_install, 0)
         do_install(spec_install, 0)
       end
     end
 
     def worker_pool
       @worker_pool ||= Bundler::Worker.new @size, "Parallel Installer", lambda {|spec_install, worker_num|
-        do_install(spec_install, worker_num)
+        case spec_install.state
+        when :enqueued
+          do_download(spec_install, worker_num)
+        when :installable
+          do_install(spec_install, worker_num)
+        else
+          spec_install
+        end
       }
     end
 
-    def do_install(spec_install, worker_num)
+    def do_download(spec_install, worker_num)
       Plugin.hook(Plugin::Events::GEM_BEFORE_INSTALL, spec_install)
+
+      gem_installer = Bundler::GemInstaller.new(
+        spec_install.spec, @installer, @standalone, worker_num, @force, @local
+      )
+
+      success, message = gem_installer.download
+
+      if success
+        spec_install.state = :downloaded
+      else
+        spec_install.error = "#{message}\n\n#{require_tree_for_spec(spec_install.spec)}"
+        spec_install.state = :failed
+      end
+
+      spec_install
+    end
+
+    def do_install(spec_install, worker_num)
       gem_installer = Bundler::GemInstaller.new(
         spec_install.spec, @installer, @standalone, worker_num, @force, @local
       )
@@ -147,9 +182,19 @@ def do_install(spec_install, worker_num)
     # Some specs might've had to wait til this spec was installed to be
     # processed so the call to `enqueue_specs` is important after every
     # dequeue.
-    def process_specs
-      worker_pool.deq
-      enqueue_specs
+    def process_specs(installed_specs)
+      spec = worker_pool.deq
+
+      if spec.installed?
+        installed_specs[spec.name] = true
+        return
+      elsif spec.failed?
+        return
+      elsif spec.ready_to_install?(installed_specs)
+        spec.state = :installable
+      end
+
+      worker_pool.enq(spec)
     end
 
     def finished_installing?
@@ -185,18 +230,15 @@ def require_tree_for_spec(spec)
     # Later we call this lambda again to install specs that depended on
     # previously installed specifications. We continue until all specs
     # are installed.
-    def enqueue_specs
-      installed_specs = {}
-      @specs.each do |spec|
-        next unless spec.installed?
-        installed_specs[spec.name] = true
-      end
-
+    def enqueue_specs(installed_specs)
       @specs.each do |spec|
-        if spec.ready_to_enqueue? && spec.dependencies_installed?(installed_specs)
-          spec.state = :enqueued
-          worker_pool.enq spec
+        if spec.installed?
+          installed_specs[spec.name] = true
+          next
         end
+
+        spec.state = :enqueued
+        worker_pool.enq spec
       end
     end
   end

bundler/lib/bundler/plugin/api/source.rb

@@ -74,6 +74,14 @@ def options_to_lock
           {}
         end
 
+        # Download the gem specified by the spec at appropriate path.
+        #
+        # A source plugin can implement this method to split the download and the
+        # installation of a gem.
+        #
+        # @return [Boolean] Whether the download of the gem succeeded.
+        def download(spec, opts); end
+
         # Install the gem specified by the spec at appropriate path.
         # `install_path` provides a sufficient default, if the source can only
         # satisfy one gem,  but is not binding.

bundler/lib/bundler/plugin/installer.rb

@@ -110,7 +110,8 @@ def install_from_specs(specs)
         paths = {}
 
         specs.each do |spec|
-          spec.source.install spec
+          spec.source.download(spec)
+          spec.source.install(spec)
 
           paths[spec.name] = spec
         end

bundler/lib/bundler/self_manager.rb

@@ -63,6 +63,7 @@ def install_and_restart_with(version)
     end
 
     def install(spec)
+      spec.source.download(spec)
       spec.source.install(spec)
     end
 

bundler/lib/bundler/source.rb

@@ -31,6 +31,8 @@ def version_message(spec, locked_spec = nil)
       message
     end
 
+    def download(*); end
+
     def can_lock?(spec)
       spec.source == self
     end

bundler/lib/bundler/source/rubygems.rb

@@ -21,6 +21,7 @@ def initialize(options = {})
         @allow_local = options["allow_local"] || false
         @prefer_local = false
         @checksum_store = Checksum::Store.new
+        @gem_installers = {}
 
         Array(options["remotes"]).reverse_each {|r| add_remote(r) }
 
@@ -162,49 +163,40 @@ def specs
         end
       end
 
-      def install(spec, options = {})
+      def download(spec, options = {})
         if (spec.default_gem? && !cached_built_in_gem(spec, local: options[:local])) || (installed?(spec) && !options[:force])
-          print_using_message "Using #{version_message(spec, options[:previous_spec])}"
-          return nil # no post-install message
+          return true
         end
 
-        path = fetch_gem_if_possible(spec, options[:previous_spec])
-        raise GemNotFound, "Could not find #{spec.file_name} for installation" unless path
-
-        return if Bundler.settings[:no_install]
-
-        install_path = rubygems_dir
-        bin_path     = Bundler.system_bindir
-
-        require_relative "../rubygems_gem_installer"
-
-        installer = Bundler::RubyGemsGemInstaller.at(
-          path,
-          security_policy: Bundler.rubygems.security_policies[Bundler.settings["trust-policy"]],
-          install_dir: install_path.to_s,
-          bin_dir: bin_path.to_s,
-          ignore_dependencies: true,
-          wrappers: true,
-          env_shebang: true,
-          build_args: options[:build_args],
-          bundler_extension_cache_path: extension_cache_path(spec)
-        )
+        installer = rubygems_gem_installer(spec, options)
 
         if spec.remote
           s = begin
             installer.spec
           rescue Gem::Package::FormatError
-            Bundler.rm_rf(path)
+            Bundler.rm_rf(installer.gem)
             raise
           rescue Gem::Security::Exception => e
             raise SecurityError,
-             "The gem #{File.basename(path, ".gem")} can't be installed because " \
+             "The gem #{installer.gem} can't be installed because " \
              "the security policy didn't allow it, with the message: #{e.message}"
           end
 
           spec.__swap__(s)
         end
 
+        spec
+      end
+
+      def install(spec, options = {})
+        if (spec.default_gem? && !cached_built_in_gem(spec, local: options[:local])) || (installed?(spec) && !options[:force])
+          print_using_message "Using #{version_message(spec, options[:previous_spec])}"
+          return nil # no post-install message
+        end
+
+        return if Bundler.settings[:no_install]
+
+        installer = rubygems_gem_installer(spec, options)
         spec.source.checksum_store.register(spec, installer.gem_checksum)
 
         message = "Installing #{version_message(spec, options[:previous_spec])}"
@@ -516,6 +508,27 @@ def extension_cache_slug(spec)
         return unless remote = spec.remote
         remote.cache_slug
       end
+
+      def rubygems_gem_installer(spec, options)
+        @gem_installers[spec.name] ||= begin
+          path = fetch_gem_if_possible(spec, options[:previous_spec])
+          raise GemNotFound, "Could not find #{spec.file_name} for installation" unless path
+
+          require_relative "../rubygems_gem_installer"
+
+          installer = Bundler::RubyGemsGemInstaller.at(
+            path,
+            security_policy: Bundler.rubygems.security_policies[Bundler.settings["trust-policy"]],
+            install_dir: rubygems_dir.to_s,
+            bin_dir: Bundler.system_bindir.to_s,
+            ignore_dependencies: true,
+            wrappers: true,
+            env_shebang: true,
+            build_args: options[:build_args],
+            bundler_extension_cache_path: extension_cache_path(spec)
+          )
+        end
+      end
     end
   end
 end