missing crossorigin tag (#56 needs more work ?)

[udf2457]

("symfony/webpack-encore-bundle": "^1.14",)

I am using encore_entry_link_tags() and encore_entry_script_tags() in my templates.

crossorigin: 'anonymous has been enabled in config/packages/webpack_encore.yaml

The behaviour I am seeing is that crossorigin="anonymous" is only being added to the<script> tags and not the <link> tags. As a result JS loads ok, but CSS fails with CRS headers.

crossorigin is supported for <link> tags and should therefore be implemented.

(Tag #42 #55 #56 )

[udf2457]

There's definitely something fishy going on here.

I don't know enough about Symfony details, so I just did a very crude test.

I edited vendor/symfony/webpack-encore-bundle/src/Asset/TagRenderer.php and inserted the following (after $attributes = array_merge in both instances):

            echo "LINK".PHP_EOL;
            print_r($this->defaultAttributes);
            print_r($this->defaultLinkAttributes);
	    echo "SCRIPT".PHP_EOL;
            print_r($this->defaultAttributes);
            print_r($this->defaultScriptAttributes);

The result was clear, crossorigin is completely missing from the link array:

                    LINK
Array
(
)
Array
(
)

But present on script:

Array
(
    [defer] => 1
    [crossorigin] => anonymous
)

I also note that @PhilETaylor test files only covered script tag and did not test link.

@Lyrkan

[Lyrkan]

Hi @udf2457,

I did some tests on my end and I'm getting the crossorigin attribute for both <script> and <link> tags.
Would you be able to share a project that shows the issue?

[udf2457]

Hi @Lyrkan ,

What version of PHP ? I'm on 8.1.7 on Debian.

I will look into seeing what I can do to share a project.

[udf2457]

Hi @Lyrkan

I've posted code up to a private repo and added you for access.

Had to be private because I pulled my code off my internal server and so although I think I've cleaned up certain confidential references there's always that little possibility of having missed anything .

I couldn't think of another way to do it, because AFAIK codesandbox wouldn't really work with the yarn/composer dependencies (or at least it would take me too much time to learn how to do it).

The content in there is basically the files changed since I first installed symfony for this project and so hopefully covers everything you'd want to look at without dumping too much extra noise !

Thanks !

[Lyrkan]

@udf2457 Thanks for the repro, I think there is an issue in your webpack_encore.yaml file: you put the crossorigin option under script_attributes... which only applies to <script> tags.

Try moving crossorigin: 'anonymous' directly under webpack_encore, it should enable it globally.

[udf2457]

@Lyrkan That worked, thanks. I appreciate the second pair of eyes !

Although to be fair its not entirely my fault, I only commented out that line which was already there. The comment above it does kind of encourage people to just do that:

If using Encore.enableIntegrityHashes() and need the crossorigin attribute (default: false, or use 'anonymous' or 'use-credentials')

Maybe those two lines should be shifted higher by default ?

[Lyrkan]

Maybe those two lines should be shifted higher by default ?

Hm, I don't see any issue with the last version of the recipe: https://github.com/symfony/recipes/blob/main/symfony/webpack-encore-bundle/1.10/config/packages/webpack_encore.yaml

Was it different when you created your project?

[udf2457]

@Lyrkan To be clearer, based on the answer you provided to my problem, and which subsequently solved my problem by implementing as you described, this is what I am suggesting:

symfony/recipes#1106

Otherwise, people (like me) will just uncomment that line and expect link to show crossorigin when infact it never will unless, like you said, that line is higher up.

[udf2457]

Also this comment (located just above script_attributes) needs to change too, since it is inherently not true:

Set attributes that will be rendered on all script and link tags

https://github.com/symfony/recipes/blob/873d9cf36aa2d8fc0211a358bb0e03ef090d83c1/symfony/webpack-encore-bundle/1.10/config/packages/webpack_encore.yaml#L7

[Lyrkan]

unless, like you said, that line is higher up

That's not what I said though, I was talking about the indentation, not the line (which doesn't matter).
With the current version of the recipe it should work if you uncomment crossorigin: 'anonymous' (i.e. remove the # and the following space).

What your file looked like:

What it should have been:

[carsonbot]

Thank you for this issue.
There has not been a lot of activity here for a while. Has this been resolved?

[udf2457]

I stopped using symphony a while back so I can't say...