C# Implementation Tracker

[silesmo]

This is an issue to track the implementation progress of C# with the mono runtime as well as the Native ahead of time LLVM compiled implementation.

• Worlds
• Interfaces
• Functions
• Integers
• Floating point numbers
• Strings
• Mono runtime tests - Dependent on (If we don't want to create 2 completely separate implementations to be able to support mono) maybe create WASM module export from [UnmanagedCallersOnly] dotnet/runtime#86985 and create WASM module import from any [DLLImport] which doesn't match known static native symbols dotnet/runtime#86984
• Native AoT LLVM runtime tests
• Results - (C#) - Basic types, Lists, Results & Variants #807
• Options
• List - (C#) - Basic types, Lists, Results & Variants #807
• Enum
• Records
• Flags
• Variants - (C#) - Basic types, Lists, Results & Variants #807
• Tuples
• Resources
  • Handles
  • Static Functions
  • Methods
• c#: Usage instructions #1074
• c#: Put shared types in a C# lib - https://github.com/bytecodealliance/cm-dotnet #1073
• Runtime tests
• Code Generation tests
  • Enabled skipped tests in

    wit-bindgen/crates/csharp/tests/codegen.rs

    Line 15 in 5f90361

    "conventions",

• bugs
  • c#: dotnet Runtime not started correctly when using strings (or heap objects) as first call to exported function  #777
  • c#: projects with <OutputType>Exe</OutputType> don't generate cabi_realloc when compiled #778
  • return pointer alignment - in some cases get error might be related to [NativeAOT-LLVM] Fix a GC hole in the new LSSA implementation  dotnet/runtimelab#2531 ((C#) - Basic types, Lists, Results & Variants #807)
  • temporarily remove C# variants runtime test #963

future work:

• Streams
• Integration with GC proposal. Related: .NET Notes WebAssembly/gc#77, [wasm][post-MVP] garbage collection proposal in .NET dotnet/runtime#94420
• Exception handling https://github.com/WebAssembly/exception-handling/tree/master
• Shared everything dynamic linking https://github.com/WebAssembly/component-model/blob/9c43f51ebf775e8397469a744d97c8575a7b7386/design/mvp/examples/SharedEverythingDynamicLinking.md

Lower priority items:

• c#: namespacing to be idomatic c#. Right now things are a mix of lower and upper case #1075
• make options implementation use c# generics - Resolved in: (C#) - Basic types, Lists, Results & Variants #807
• c#: fix imports so they are only included if needed #1076
• c#: create a cli option to generate the csproj and replace that for the tests. #1077
• c#: only use version info if required #1078

@yowl @jsturtevant @danbugs

[jsturtevant]

Since we now have most of the core types covered, I've split out the remaining items to their own issues and we can close this.