Broken semver

[madjam002]

A patch version of redbox-react was published an hour ago but the peer dependency was changed to only support React 15.

Our CI is now failing with:

error   17-Jun-2016 16:17:59    npm ERR! peerinvalid The package react@0.14.8 does not satisfy its siblings' peerDependencies requirements!
...
error   17-Jun-2016 16:17:59    npm ERR! peerinvalid Peer redbox-react@1.2.7 wants react@^15.0.0
...

Can we change this to a major version bump? Dropping support for React 0.14 is a breaking change.
It would be good if we could get a patch version on the v1 branch which is just an old version which supports React 0.14 so that we don't break compatibility for other users.

Thanks

[selaromi]

Same issue here. After uploading a new container, this issue occured during building:

´´´
npm ERR! peer dep missing: react@^15.0.0, required by redbox-react@1.2.7
npm ERR! peer dep missing: react@^15.1.0, required by react-dom@15.1.0
´´´

And then react-transform-catch-errors would stop working. Just fix the version to the previous (or upgrade react to avoid this issues.

[madjam002]

Yup we've locked down to a previous version, would be nice if this was fixed here though too.

[nagaskolli]

Yes, can we please change this to a major version? We have some dependencies (react-swipeable-views for example) that in turn depends on redbox-react. We cannot even lock down the version.

[davidpfahler]

Sorry for this breaking change! This one slipped through the cracks. Unfortunately, also no one besides me caught it on the PR. I will try to fix this as soon as I'm back at my computer.

[davidpfahler]

What it be better to bring back react 0.14 support? If so, as a fix or major change?

[davidpfahler]

Dear all, I'm sorry for breaking your builds. I decided to release a new fix version (=minor) that reenables support for react 0.14. Your broken builds should automatically unbreak this way. Please let me know what you think about this and if your builds are OK now.

[c089]

@davidpfahler: Thanks for your work. Unfortunately I'm still seeing the unmet peer dep with 1.2.8 on a react 14 project:

├─┬ redbox-react@1.2.8 
│ ├── UNMET PEER DEPENDENCY react@^15.1.0

[davidpfahler]

@c089 Do you know why? Afaik, the changes I made should be sufficient. I'd need more detail to investigate your problem.

[c089]

Unfortunately no idea yet, I was hoping it's an obvious thing ;) I'll try to isolate the problem later today.

[macklinu]

A project I'm working on is using React 0.14 and has recently started failing on CI with the error message:

Error: The package react does not satisfy its siblings' peerDependencies requirements!

I ran npm ls react-dom from the root project directory:

├─┬ babel-preset-react-hmre@1.1.1
│ └─┬ redbox-react@1.2.8
│   ├── UNMET PEER DEPENDENCY react@^15.1.0
│   └── react-dom@15.1.0
└── react-dom@0.14.8

npm ERR! peer dep missing: react@^15.1.0, required by react-dom@15.1.0

It looks like v1.2.8 of redbox-react requires react-dom: ^15.1.0 as a dependency, and I think this may be the problem.

I cloned redbox-react and babel-preset-react-hmre and made the following changes locally:

• redbox-react: loosened the react-dom dependency: "react-dom": "^0.14.0 || ^15.0.0"
• babel-preset-react-hmre: changed package.json to use the updated redbox-react dependency
• my project: changed package.json to use the updated babel-preset-react-hmre dependency

I ran rm -rf node_modules && npm install on my project locally, and it succeeded. I'll open a PR with the changes. 🎉