You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Following up from #15668, opening existing workspaces with a different editor is still a friction as it remains a user preference you have to change every time.
Now that start with options is available on projects and branches lists (#15668) could it make sense to also replace the Open menu on the workspace more actions context menu with Open … and prompt user to select a different editor when re-opening an existing workspace?
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered:
I believe that if a user ever starts or restarts, regardless of where they comes from, they should see a consistent and reliable interface. It should serve as:
a confirmation of what is about to happen
an opportunity to modify the parameters (editor, workspace class, etc.)
an opportunity to cancel
I don't believe we need additional options in menus like "Open with options" or "Open ...". There should just be "Open" and this unified experience.
... they should see a consistent and reliable interface.
This sounds like a good MVC forward and provides more robust user control and freedom. It's also aligned with our product design principles[1]: Less choices, more control[1][2][3].
☝️ This means, we could replace all workspace start URLs with prefixing with ?showOptions=true# and users will always get prompted to select the other options.
One small downside in terms of usability with this approach could be that this will always require at least two clicks instead of one for users to open a workspace, but sounds like the trade-off could be worth it.
Alternatively, we could skip the step to select options when directly selecting a workspace from the workspaces list using the row or workspace ID, and keep the prompt in all other cases like:
Workspace more actions dropdown
Project cards more action dropdown
Project branches new workspace button
Prebuild new workspace button
I'll close this in favor of #15979 (Cc @svenefftinge) as it already mentions the ability for the exception:
Show the create workspace dialog by default to all workspace creation requests unless there is an explicit argument to skip it (i.e. turn the logic around).
Problem to solve
Following up from #15668, opening existing workspaces with a different editor is still a friction as it remains a user preference you have to change every time.
Cc @svenefftinge because #15567
Cc @loujaybee because #13580
Proposal
From the relevant discussions[1][2] (internal):
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: