Skip to content

Conversation

@mikemcdougall
Copy link
Collaborator

Summary

  • Implements OGC API Features Items endpoint (GET /ogc/features/collections/{collectionId}/items)
  • Adds comprehensive bbox parameter support for spatial filtering
  • Ensures DRY compliance by reusing existing FeatureServer infrastructure
  • Provides complete test coverage with 11 passing OGC integration tests

Technical Implementation

  • Shared Query Pipeline: Reuses IFeatureStore and IQueryFormatter from FeatureServer
  • OGC Compliance: Supports standard bbox format (minx,miny,maxx,maxy)
  • Proper Content Types: Returns application/geo+json for GeoJSON responses
  • Spatial Filtering: Implements WKB polygon generation for bbox queries
  • Error Handling: Comprehensive validation with appropriate HTTP status codes

Test Coverage

✅ All 11 OGC API Features tests passing:

  • Landing page and conformance endpoints
  • Collections listing and metadata
  • Items endpoint with bbox filtering
  • Error scenarios (invalid bbox, missing collections)

Architecture Compliance

  • No DRY violations: Shared infrastructure prevents code duplication
  • Vertical slice organization: OGC features grouped cohesively
  • Dependency limits: Follows architectural constraints
  • AOT compatibility: Uses proper JSON contexts

Production Notes

  • Current WKB generation is simplified for MVP
  • TODO: Replace with NetTopologySuite for production geometry handling
  • Spatial filtering works correctly for test scenarios

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Mike McDougall and others added 2 commits December 21, 2025 14:33
)

- Add HandleGetItems method with bbox parameter support
- Implement shared query pipeline using existing IFeatureStore and IQueryFormatter
- Support OGC-compliant bbox format (minx,miny,maxx,maxy)
- Return proper application/geo+json content type
- Add comprehensive test coverage including bbox and error scenarios
- Ensure DRY compliance by reusing FeatureServer infrastructure
- Generate simple WKB polygon for spatial filtering (production TODO: use NetTopologySuite)

All 11 OGC API Features tests passing successfully.

🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code)

Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4 <[email protected]>
- Add missing final newlines to OgcModels.cs, OgcFeaturesEndpoints.cs, and OgcFeaturesEndpointTests.cs
- Fix import ordering in Program.cs
- Ensures CI format check passes
@github-actions
Copy link

🤖 LLM Architecture Review

Assessment: APPROVED

🏗️ Architecture Review Summary

✅ Good Patterns Found:

  • Comprehensive XML documentation on public types in OgcModels.cs and OgcFeaturesEndpoints.cs, ensuring good API documentation and maintainability.
  • Effective use of Minimal API patterns in OgcFeaturesEndpoints.cs, aligning with the project's architectural direction to avoid the controller-based model.
  • Proper dependency injection and service configuration in Program.cs, demonstrating clean architecture principles by isolating infrastructure setup from business logic.
  • Extensive test coverage in OgcFeaturesEndpointTests.cs, including detailed integration tests that validate both functionality and compliance with OGC standards.

⚠️ Architecture Concerns:

  • Performance Concerns: Usage of Task.Result or similar blocking calls were not found, which is good. However, the manual WKB creation in OgcFeaturesEndpoints.cs might be optimized or replaced with a more efficient library to avoid potential performance bottlenecks.

💡 Recommendations:

  • Optimize Spatial Data Handling: Consider using a library like NetTopologySuite for handling spatial data to improve performance and accuracy. Replace the placeholder WKB generation with a robust implementation.
    // Example using NetTopologySuite for better WKB handling
    var geometryFactory = new NetTopologySuite.Geometries.GeometryFactory(new NetTopologySuite.Geometries.PrecisionModel(), 4326);
    var envelope = new NetTopologySuite.Geometries.Envelope(minX, maxX, minY, maxY);
    var polygon = geometryFactory.ToGeometry(envelope);
    var wkbWriter = new NetTopologySuite.IO.WKBWriter();
    var wkb = wkbWriter.Write(polygon);

📚 Educational Notes:

  • Why Minimal APIs Matter: By using Minimal APIs, the project benefits from reduced boilerplate, clearer routing and endpoint definitions, and improved testability. This approach aligns with modern .NET practices and helps maintain clean architecture by keeping the infrastructure and business logic decoupled.
  • Importance of Proper Spatial Data Handling: Efficient handling of spatial data is crucial in geospatial applications for performance and accuracy. Using specialized libraries like NetTopologySuite ensures that spatial operations are performed correctly and efficiently, leveraging years of optimization and industry standards.

Overall Assessment: APPROVED

The code review reveals a well-structured approach adhering to the project's architectural standards. The use of Minimal APIs, comprehensive testing, and adherence to OGC standards are particularly commendable. While there are recommendations for optimizing spatial data handling, the current implementation meets the project's critical architectural requirements.


Automated architectural analysis powered by OpenAI GPT-4
This review focuses on architectural patterns and design decisions
Human review still recommended for complex changes

Integrates comprehensive OGC API Features implementation by adding Items endpoint to existing collections functionality:

**Added OGC Items endpoint functionality:**
- GET /ogc/features/collections/{collectionId}/items endpoint with bbox filtering
- HandleGetItems method with comprehensive error handling
- Spatial filtering using WKB envelope geometry for bbox queries
- Integration with existing FeatureQuery and QueryFormatter pipeline (DRY principle)

**Enhanced test coverage:**
- Added TestFeatureStore service for items endpoint testing
- 4 new integration tests covering valid collection, bbox filtering, error cases
- All tests passing with proper API surface coverage

**Complete OGC API Features compliance:**
Now supports all core endpoints:
- GET /ogc/features (landing page)
- GET /ogc/features/conformance
- GET /ogc/features/collections (list)
- GET /ogc/features/collections/{id} (metadata)
- GET /ogc/features/collections/{id}/items (features with bbox filtering)

Maintains existing architecture patterns and reuses shared infrastructure.
@mikemcdougall mikemcdougall merged commit b4937b7 into trunk Dec 22, 2025
11 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants