resolve snrefs for child items#373
Conversation
|
|
| self._table_row = odxlinks.resolve(self.table_row_ref, TableRow) | ||
| else: | ||
| self._table_row = odxlinks.resolve(self.table_row_ref) | ||
| self._table_row._resolve_odxlinks(odxlinks) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Without this line, the parser will raise exception on below line, said that the "table" of tablerow does not exist.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I see. That said, _resolve_odxlinks() must not be called for objects that are the result of a reference resolution lest there be cyclic reference resolution hell. as an alternative to this patch line 94 should better be replaced by
self._table = odxlinks.resolve(self._table_row.table_ref, Table)in this case, the .table property below should also be simplified to
@property
def table(self) -> "Table":
return self._tableThere was a problem hiding this comment.
do you want you change the PR to only fix this issue (and remove the SNREF changes) or do you prefer if I do it?
| for response in self._positive_responses: | ||
| response._resolve_snrefs(context) | ||
| for response in self._negative_responses: | ||
| response._resolve_snrefs(context) |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
while this might fix the specific problem which you've encountered, this is pretty much a coincidence: this causes the referenced objects to be retargeted to basically the last ECU variant encountered during the reference resolution procedure. If you're looking at another diagnostic layer, e.g. the base variant, its snrefs will have been incorrectly resolved...
There was a problem hiding this comment.
yes, u are correct. So with this change, I need to call _resolve_snrefs again before I try to visit other variants. Since the child variant would use parent objects (References) directly, I cannot find other solutions for this problem.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I guess #374 might make your life considerably easier?!
|
I suppose that this has become obsolete with #374. I'll close this for now... |
3 participants
for issue #368, current solution is to resolve snrefs based on current variant context before trying to access it. To get the correct result, the snrefs of child items should be resolved when calling its parent's _resolve_snrefs. So I add code to do the work for some missing items