indent after one-line if statement without semicolon

[camsteffen]

This is incorrectly indented

if(1) return
    console.log('foo')

[qstrahl]

Oh man, I have a feeling this one is going to be absurdly difficult to solve. Thanks for the report.

[camsteffen]

Admittedly I am not familiar with the code, but shouldn't this be pretty simple? If there is anything after the parenthesis, then that is the if block and the next line is not.

[camsteffen]

I decided to get my hands dirty.

Looking at indent/javascript.vim...

The problem is that s:InOneLineScope(lnum) evaluates true (non-zero) with the line if(1) return. I believe the function would be better named BeginsOneLineScope. Fixing it will require changing s:one_line_scope_regex so that it does not match when there is a statement following the if/for/while/.... I'm not very good at Vim regular expressions but I will keep at it unless someone wants to step in.

[camsteffen]

Related to #192 and #253

[qstrahl]

Thanks for the detective work, @cambunctious!

Using regexes for this stuff makes me throw up in my mouth a bit, but unless/until we can make use of the underlying syntax groups to do this stuff, it's pretty unavoidable... I have a knack for vim regex so I'll take a crack at getting something in place that won't break under the smallest amount of pressure, and hopefully we'll be able to put this to bed for now.

[qstrahl]

Also, with regard to:

Admittedly I am not familiar with the code, but shouldn't this be pretty simple? If there is anything after the parenthesis, then that is the if block and the next line is not.

Corner cases. Consider the following:

if (something) { doLittle(); } else
    bigNamedVariable.doTonsOfStuffHolyCrapThisMethodNameIsSoConvenientlyDescriptive();

I don't have a very good idea of how all those indent-related functions operate, but I assume that cases like the above could throw it for a loop. We can ignore those cases, but only until somebody posts an issue here complaining that it doesn't work. =P

[camsteffen]

Corner cases.

Blast!

Maybe s:InOneLineScope(lnum) could work something like this:

1. if the line ends with else, return true
2. If the line ends with if|while|for followed by a parenthetical, return true
3. return false

I see the tricky part is the parenthetical with regex. Is it possible to use the % command to find matching parenthesis? If so, begin step 2 by detecting a ) at the end of the line and work backwards.

[qstrahl]

I will have to take a look at it, but using normal commands/moving the
cursor around sounds like it could break stuff, if it's even possible.
Don't worry, I'll figure something out. Just gotta dive into the code. =)

On Tue, 1 Sep 2015 17:11 Cameron Steffen [email protected] wrote:

Maybe s:InOneLineScope(lnum) could work something like this:

1. if the line ends with else, return true
2. If the line ends with if|while|for followed by a parenthetical,
   return true
3. return false

I see the tricky part is the parenthetical with regex. Is it possible to
use the % command to find matching parenthesis? If so, start step 2 by
detecting a ) at the end of the line.

—
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub
#291 (comment)
.

[evgenyzinoviev]

Just faced this problem. I've never used regular expressions in vimscript before, so I'm almost sure that my solution is completely wrong and dirty, but it seems to work for me for now (tested for a few seconds lol)

let s:one_line_scope_regex = '\<\%(if\|for\|while\)\>\s*([^)]*)\s*' . s:line_term
let s:one_line_scope_regex_else = 'else\s*' . s:line_term

...

function s:InOneLineScope(lnum)
  let msl = s:GetMSL(a:lnum, 1)
  if msl > 0 && (s:Match(msl, s:one_line_scope_regex) || s:Match(msl, s:one_line_scope_regex_else))
    return msl
  endif
  return 0
endfunction

[camsteffen]

I already have a pull request submitted for this.