Protected case class constructor -> non-public apply

compiler/src/dotty/tools/dotc/ast/Desugar.scala

@@ -693,23 +693,11 @@ object desugar {
     // For all other classes, the parent is AnyRef.
     val companions =
       if (isCaseClass) {
-
-        // true if access to the apply method has to be restricted
-        // i.e. if the case class constructor is either private or qualified private
-        def restrictedAccess = {
-          val mods = constr1.mods
-          mods.is(Private) || (!mods.is(Protected) && mods.hasPrivateWithin)
-        }
-
         val applyMeths =
           if (mods.is(Abstract)) Nil
           else {
-            val copiedFlagsMask = copiedAccessFlags & Private
-            val appMods = {
-              val mods = Modifiers(Synthetic | constr1.mods.flags & copiedFlagsMask)
-              if (restrictedAccess) mods.withPrivateWithin(constr1.mods.privateWithin)
-              else mods
-            }
+            val appMods =
+              Modifiers(Synthetic | constr1.mods.flags & copiedAccessFlags).withPrivateWithin(constr1.mods.privateWithin)
             val appParamss =
               derivedVparamss.nestedZipWithConserve(constrVparamss)((ap, cp) =>
                 ap.withMods(ap.mods | (cp.mods.flags & HasDefault)))

tests/neg/caseclass-access.scala

@@ -1,12 +1,14 @@
 case class A private (i: Int)
 object A
 object ATest {
+  def a0: A = new A(0) // error: constructor is private
   def a1: A = A(1) // error: apply is private
   def a2: A = a1.copy(2) // error: copy is private
 }
 
 case class B private (i: Int) // ok: no user-defined companion object
 object BTest {
+  def b0: B = new B(0) // error: constructor is private
   def b1: B = B(1) // error: apply is private
   def b2: B = b1.copy(2) // error: copy is private
 }
@@ -19,24 +21,30 @@ object qualified_private {
 }
 object QPrivTest {
   import qualified_private.*
+  def c0: C = new C(0) // error: constructor is private
   def c1: C = C(1) // error: apply is private
   def c2: C = c1.copy(2) // error: copy is private
 
+  def d0: D = new D(0) // error: constructor is private
   def d1: D = D(1) // error: apply is private
   def d2: D = d1.copy(2) // error: copy is private
 }
 
 case class E protected (i: Int)
 object ETest {
-  def e1: E = E(1)
-  def e2: E = e2.copy(2) // error: copy is protected
+  def e0: E = new E(0) // error: constructor is protected
+  def e1: E = E(1) // error: apply is protected
+  def e2: E = e1.copy(2) // error: copy is protected
+  def eta: Int => E = E // error: apply is protected
 }
 
 object qualified_protected {
   case class F protected[qualified_protected] (i: Int)
 }
 object QProtTest {
   import qualified_protected.*
-  def f1: F = F(1)
-  def f2: F = f2.copy(2) // error: copy is protected
+  def f0: F = new F(0) // error: constructor is protected
+  def f1: F = F(1) // error: apply is protected
+  def f2: F = f1.copy(2) // error: copy is protected
+  def eta: Int => F = F // error: apply is protected
 }

tests/neg/i14187.scala

@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
+sealed case class Foo protected (i: Int, j: Int)
+
+final class Bar(n: Int) extends Foo(n, n)
+
+class Other:
+  def foo  = Foo(1, 2)       // error
+  def foo2 = Foo.apply(1, 2) // error

tests/pos/caseclass-access.scala

@@ -1,47 +1,45 @@
 case class A private (i: Int)
 object A {
+  def a0 = new A(0)    // constructor is accessible in companion
   def a = A(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible in companion
 }
 
 case class B private (i: Int) { // no user-defined companion object, should compile
+  def b0 = new B(0)    // constructor is accessible
   def b = B(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible
 }
 
 object qualified_private {
   case class A private[qualified_private] (i: Int)
   object A {
+    def a0 = new A(0)    // constructor is accessible in companion
     def a = A(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible in companion
   }
 
+  def a0 = new A(0)    // constructor is accessible in qualified_private object
   def a = A(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible in qualified_private object
 
   case class B private[qualified_private] (i: Int) { // no user-defined companion object, should compile
+    def b0 = new B(0)    // constructor is accessible
     def b = B(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible
   }
 
+  def b0 = new B(0)    // constructor is accessible in qualified_private object
   def b = B(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible in qualified_private object
 }
 
 case class C protected (i: Int)
 class CSub extends C(1) {
   def c = copy(2) // copy is accessible in subclass
 }
-object CTest {
-  def c = C(1) // apply is public
-}
 
 object qualified_protected {
   case class C protected[qualified_protected] (i: Int)
   class CSub extends C(1) {
     def c = copy(2) // copy is accessible in subclass
   }
-  object CTest {
-    def c = C(1) // apply is public
-    def checkExtendsFunction: Int => C = C // companion extends (Int  => C)
-  }
+  def eta: Int => C = C // can eta-expand C.apply method
 
-  def c = C(1).copy(2)
-}
-object CQualifiedTest {
-  def c = qualified_protected.C(1) // apply is public
+  def c0 = new C(0)    // constructor is accessible in qualified_protected object
+  def c = C(1).copy(2) // apply and copy are accessible in qualified_protected object
 }