Skip to content

Incorrect Handling of ".include" in Identifiers in Souffle Parser #2497

@Mingtao521

Description

@Mingtao521

I noticed a issue in the Souffle parser when handling ".include" within identifiers. Here is an example illustrating the problem:

.decl test(b: symbol)
test(b) :- A.includeB(b).
.output test(IO=stdout)

.comp A_comp {
    .decl includeB(b: symbol)
    includeB("B").
}
.init A = A_comp

Compiling this Datalog program with Souffle results in the following errors:

Error: syntax error, unexpected invalid token in file test.dl at line 2
test(b) :- A.includeB(b).
--------------------^-----
Error: unexpected B in file test.dl at line 2
test(b) :- A.includeB(b).
--------------------^-----
2 errors generated, evaluation aborted

I suspect the issue lies within Souffle's lexer, which incorrectly recognizes ".include" as a keyword or directive, rather than part of an identifier. Relevant code can be found in src/parser/scanner.ll on lines 156-159:

".include"                            {
                                        yyinfo.LastIncludeDirectiveLoc = yylloc;
                                        BEGIN(INCLUDE);
                                      }

I think the correct handling of ".include" should be similar to other directives like ".decl" or ".functor," where it should only be treated as a directive declaration when followed by one or more spaces.

To test my hypothesis, I modified line 156 in scanner.ll to:

".include"/{WS}                       {

Compiling the above Datalog program with modified Souffle produces the following output:

---------------
test
===============
B
===============

If this issue is really a bug, I am happy to submit a pull request to fix it.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions